In a sweeping escalation of its crackdown on transgender participation in sports, the Trump administration has accused the University of Pennsylvania of violating Title IX by allowing transgender swimmer Lia Thomas to compete on the women’s swim team during the 2021–2022 season.
The U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights issued a ruling Monday claiming that Penn “denied women equal opportunities by permitting males to compete in women’s intercollegiate athletics and to occupy women-only intimate facilities.” The statement did not name Thomas directly but repeatedly referenced events and figures associated with her tenure at the university.
Title IX, a federal civil rights law enacted in 1972, prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex in education programs and activities receiving federal financial assistance. The Trump administration’s interpretation of Title IX now explicitly excludes transgender women from women’s sports—a sharp deviation from past guidance issued by the same department under previous administrations.
Craig Trainor, Acting Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights, stated that Penn must take immediate action or face further consequences, including loss of federal funding. The department gave Penn ten days to comply with several demands: publicly declare it will follow the administration’s new Title IX interpretation, retroactively strip records and awards from transgender athletes, and send formal apology letters to female athletes impacted by Thomas’s competition.
This ruling follows an earlier decision in March to suspend approximately $175 million in federal funding to the Ivy League university. Those funds were tied to programs supported by the Department of Defense and the Department of Health and Human Services.
A university spokesperson reiterated that Penn “has always complied with NCAA and Ivy League policies governing athlete eligibility” and noted that the university had never been instructed to take retroactive disciplinary action before now.
The move has sparked deep concern within academic and LGBTQ+ advocacy circles. More than 600 Penn faculty members have signed a letter urging the university to resist federal overreach and consider legal action. An additional 1,100 students and staff have voiced support for preserving nondiscrimination policies and the rights of transgender community members.
“This is a targeted attack, not just on transgender athletes but on the academic independence of our institutions,” wrote a faculty group in The Daily Pennsylvanian. “We cannot allow political pressure to dictate who belongs in our classrooms, labs, or on our teams.”
The Trump administration’s actions have also drawn criticism for their underlying contradiction: while accusing Penn of violating Title IX, they are simultaneously working to dismantle the very department they’re using to enforce it. President Trump and several Republican leaders have previously called for the elimination of the Department of Education, arguing it represents government overreach.
For transgender students and their allies, this case isn’t just about swimming. It represents a broader effort to delegitimize trans identities in public life, particularly in education and athletics. Lia Thomas, who became the first openly transgender athlete to win an NCAA Division I title in 2022, remains a flashpoint in this debate; celebrated by some as a pioneer and targeted by others as a scapegoat.
This is not the only Title IX case under investigation. The administration has also launched inquiries into San Jose State University and the Massachusetts Interscholastic Athletic Association over similar allegations of allowing transgender athletes to compete in women’s sports.
Meanwhile, advocacy groups, including the ACLU and the Human Rights Campaign, have condemned the administration’s latest actions as a gross misapplication of civil rights law. “Title IX was written to expand opportunity, not to weaponize exclusion,” said a joint statement from several civil rights organizations released Monday.
At the center of this firestorm are the transgender students and athletes who must now navigate a rapidly shifting legal and political landscape. For them, participation in sports is not about ideology or controversy—it’s about belonging.
As Penn weighs its next steps, pressure continues to mount from faculty, students, alumni, and national higher education leaders urging the school to stand firm. Penn President J. Larry Jameson, who recently signed a statement opposing “undue government intrusion,” has yet to comment on the Department of Education’s latest ultimatum.
Whether Penn complies or fights back may determine not just its own future, but the future of Title IX’s interpretation in a post-truth political climate.
Would you like a companion op-ed written from the perspective of a trans athlete or student?
